Farmers' Day Off
“When I improvise on my flute for the Haitians they look at each other and nod, saying the Creole words for ‘bird spirit.’ They know that the voice that was singing through the empty tube of the flute was not my person, but the spirit voice that sang through an empty self, my ego temporarily suspended, my shell possessed by a lesser god”—poet and singer Berrien Thorn (1980s)
The migrant farmworkers that Berrien Thorn encountered were defined in terms of work: their travel to New York state, usually paid according to the volume they harvested, and fed enough food to keep working the next day. If it rained and they couldn’t work, they weren’t paid. Besides needful labor in the field and perhaps washing clothes, there was little interest in the rest of their lives. As Thorn eloquently puts it, “Brutal work stooping to pull potatoes from the muck is the bottom of this odd context. Going upright into the trees for fruit is the top” (162). Where then did the spirit travel outside of this narrow range?
Efforts to foster or even document the full lives of migrant workers have been rare; besides the Geneseo Migrant Center, antecedents like the United Farm Workers Union (during the 1950s-60s) or various programs during the 1930s Works Progress Administration stand as exceptions. There is even less known about the lives of 19th-century hired hands, perhaps because farmers themselves maintained a puritanical attitude toward work. One lamented that “Our seasons are so short, help so scarce, and there is so much to do, that it is almost impossible to find time to attend to mental improvement, and the cultivation of social feelings.” The solution? Visit neighbors during the off-season and “Talk over your agricultural plans and prospects” (“Farmers”). Another farmer named Izaak Huff argued that “plain, hard-working men require plain, hard-working wives; not fine, fashionable young ladies, who will despise their husbands because they drive the plow or wield an axe, and labor for the better support of their families.” Embroidering, “rattling the keys of the piano,” dancing, reading—these and other pursuits would “uneducate them for the station of life which God destined them to fill” (130).
Interestingly, the editor pushed back against this “tirade” and elsewhere argued that “elegant pursuits are not...incompatible with good housewifery” (“ A Few Words”). Another writer acknowledged that “What every man requires when the day is done, is gentle recreation, something between work and play, which shall break the train of moody thought, repair the waste of nervous elasticity, and put the jaded mind in good humor with itself and others” (Working-man). Ironically, this writer suggested gardening as a recreation for farmers, but there were others who advocated for reading and creative pastimes.
The influential Grange movement--whose first hall was opened in Fredonia, NY in 1878--recognized the necessity for cultivating personal and social expression outside of working hours. Drawing upon an agricultural analogy, one writer asserted that a farmer’s children “should live under a genial sun, be fed with refreshing showers, and then receive the care of a wise, social culturalist,” but there is no mention of caring for hired hands (“Farmer’s Fireside” 142-143). Taking as our guide all of the activities nurtured by the Geneseo Migrant Center, we’re left to infer unrecorded traditions among hired laborers: they must have read, written, recited, carved, drawn, sung, played instruments, knitted, embroidered, quilted, danced, told stories, improvised, cooked, arranged flowers, studied, and simply enjoyed talking to each other. All of the things anyone would want to do.
Works Consulted
-- “The Farmer’s Fireside.” The Genesee Farmer 26.5 (May 1865): 142-143. Courtesy of Internet Archive.
-- “Farmers Should Visit More.” The Genesee Farmer 25.8 (Aug. 1864): 238. Courtesy of Internet Archive.
-- “A Few Words About Bread.” The Genesee Farmer 15.7 (July 1854): 225. Courtesy of Internet Archive.
-- Huff, Izaak. “Letter from Oak Hill.” The Genesee Farmer 16.4 (April 1855): 129-130. Courtesy of Internet Archive.
-- Thorn, Berrien. “Field Notes.” Journal of the New York Folklore Society 13.1-2 (Winter-Spring 1987): 162-166.
-- Working-man. “The Workingman’s Garden and Grounds.” The Genesee Farmer 2.1 (Jan. 1841): 15. Courtesy of Internet Archive.